The state of soccer
Two happy nations, one struggling sport – World Soccer – Yahoo! Sports
Related Posts
Subscribe
|
Print
|
Share
|
Comments


I think FIFA has an opportunity to use video review in a constructive way here…retroactive penalization for diving behavior. Let the refs do their job as they currently are, but free them up to focus more on the match and less on the play acting. If they see something, call it, if they don’t, don’t worry about it as the game will be reviewed in full on tape after the fact and if any unflagged foolishness is seen, that player gets penalized. I say get harsh with the divers and sit them out a match…treat it like a red card. They’ll soon get the point and adjust their play. What happened in this Cup was disgraceful.




i agree, mostly, they should allow video evidence and i think repeated diving should result in suspension, as long at it’s a clear dive, sometime its just exaggerating or overacting, or the player looses balance after a more harmless touch. i also think it takes a lot of chuzpe to call for a freekick or even a card after a dive.




I have to agree with the linked article, on field we’ve seen a near complete absence of sportsmanship. I can’t recall a world cup which has been so violent and full of cheating (think of Zizou, Rooney, Holland/Portugal, Argentina after the shootout and all the diving). Off the field in Germany and in Pubs around the world by all accounts the fans have been excellent, so its a real mixed bag.
Posted from
Australia




If you’re bringing in post-match reviewing, I really don’t think you need to change the penalty that accrues from an offence at all(such as dealing out red cards rather than yellow for diving as Stuart suggests). The problem we currently have is that players know that A) the chances of getting penalised for diving are very small and B) if they hear nothing immediately from the ref they’re in the clear – that’s why they do it.
Just introducing post-match reviews pulls the rug from under both. Let’s say you dive once in a match. In the first instance, you know damn well you just play-acted and that some group of people are going to look over the footage with a fine-toothed comb. You don’t know how you just looked on camera, whether your acting was good enough, whether the camera caught you well enough…. and so on. It doesn’t matter whether or not the reviewing panel takes a fairly conservative approach to declaring a dive or not (within reason, of course)- it really doesn’t. You’ve got that hanging over your head FOR THE REST OF THE MATCH. You’ll think pretty long and hard about doing it again and risking missing the next one. In fact, you’ll think pretty damn hard about doing it the first time knowing that big brother is watching. The same holds for any number of nefarious acts. You really can use video evidence without disrupting play one iota.
The only real problem from FIFA’s point of view is in instances where some form of cheating can be seen as deciding the game. Hand out a post-match penalty for the act here and you’re pretty much admitting the outcome is, at very least, questionable – which looks pretty bad. But I think that in any case people will be less likely to get creative in the first place and in the second, well, when the whole freakin’ world will see such acts anyway FIFA loses more face by ignoring them if you ask me.
Posted from
Australia




AF I can’t agree more. I think if such a change was introduced well before the world cup in all major domestic leagues then the players will all have adapted to it and be unlikely to dive in situations in which they will get caught. They might still be diving, but it will be far less obvious so game deciding moments would be only rarely overturned.
Having said that I think it is fine to say both ‘the referee is allowed to make mistakes’ AND that ‘cheating players will be fined/banned/carded retrospectively’. So I don’t believe its inconsistent to award a yellow card for a dive after the match even if the ref gave a penalty for it in the game (its the lesser of two evils).
Posted from
Australia




Austalia huh?…I WISH I were in Australia…




So does anyone know of any new up and coming players that could feature for 2008?
Posted from
United Kingdom




I have to say the aussi showed extreme strength of character on and off the pitch when they where robbed by the italians
who says cheating doesnt win
it wins the big one in this case
2 refs – video footage we live in the 21st century – lets bring the game there as well – im amazed that the sponsors havent threatened to pull the plugg as they lose out as well when the cheating robs a team of a deserved place
oh and I think the french should have won and that form an enlishman scary
Posted from
United Kingdom




Lol @ Wobbs but I agree with you. I wish England and Germany had been in the finals. Though they are both physical teams, they play “futbal” with their hearts, head and legs… Italia was very disappointing and the way they won (Frings ban, diving, trash talk, corruption), makes me think that FIFA has to go by their own rules. Hope they will next time around.
Posted from
United States




and… Wobbs, the sponsors kept Zidane on the payroll. Noble, noble, noble. I am glad they did.
Posted from
United States


Comments are closed
Send Your Tips!
Email tips[at]worldcupblog[dot]org
Germany Club Football News
- Robbery in Ausburg
- Demolition Derby, Werder-Style
- CL Match Preview: Rangers v. VfB Stuttgart
- Louis van Gaal's Nursery
- Matchday 13: Danger! Hyperbole ahead!
More Europe Blogs
France World Cup Blog
791 Articles | 10,344 Comments
Croatia World Cup Blog
192 Articles | 1,821 Comments
Czech Republic World Cup Blog
196 Articles | 320 Comments
England World Cup Team Blog
812 Articles | 2,772 Comments
Germany World Cup Blog Blog
485 Articles | 3,098 Comments
Italy World Cup Blog
567 Articles | 21,807 Comments
Netherlands World Cup Blog
2,016 Articles | 26,986 Comments
Poland World Cup Blog
353 Articles | 4,202 Comments
Portugal World Cup Blog
453 Articles | 7,018 Comments
Serbia World Cup Team Blog
168 Articles | 847 Comments
Spain World Cup Blog
235 Articles | 1,926 Comments
Sweden World Cup Blog
151 Articles | 318 Comments
Switzerland World Cup Blog
217 Articles | 327 Comments
Ukraine World Cup Team Blog
120 Articles | 806 Comments
Greece World Cup Blog
142 Articles | 70 Comments
Russia World Cup Blog
81 Articles | 143 Comments
Scotland World Cup Team Blog
101 Articles | 108 Comments
Ireland World Cup Team Blog
55 Articles | 122 Comments
Norway World Cup Team Blog
9 Articles | 6 Comments
Turkey World Cup Blog
39 Articles | 293 Comments
Romania World Cup Blog
78 Articles | 281 Comments
Austria World Cup Blog
111 Articles | 117 Comments
Denmark World Cup Team Blog
8 Articles | 27 Comments
Albania World Cup Team Blog
4 Articles | 8 Comments
Belgium World Cup Team Blog
49 Articles | 59 Comments
Wales World Cup Team Blog
61 Articles | 17 Comments
Bosnia World Cup Team Blog
31 Articles | 87 Comments
Israel World Cup Team Blog
22 Articles | 18 Comments
Monthly Archives
World 







